TrimBil

Is my roof replacement quote too high? A 10-minute check

How to tell if a roof replacement quote is fair: what the total should cover, the lines that hide padding, and the questions to send before you sign.

  • TrimBil Team
  • 2026-11-18
  • 6 min read

A roof is one of the biggest checks most homeowners ever write, and most people sign after seeing one or two quotes. You don't need to be a roofer to tell whether a quote is reasonable. You need ten minutes, the quote in front of you, and the right questions.

1. Find the size of the job

Roofers price by the "square" - 100 square feet of roof. Look for the number of squares on the quote. If it isn't there, ask for it. Without a size you can't compare two quotes, and a quote that hides the size is harder to hold to account if the crew finds "extra" work later.

2. Check what the total actually covers

A complete replacement quote should name: tear-off and disposal of the old roof (and how many layers), the shingle brand and product line, the underlayment, flashing, drip edge and ventilation, the permit, clean-up, and labour. If any of these are missing, the price may look low now and grow later through change orders.

3. Look for the lines that hide padding

Vague lines are where money disappears. "Misc.", "materials" or "labour and materials" as a single number tells you nothing. Ask for these to be itemised. A good contractor can tell you what's inside each line in one email.

4. Read the payment terms

A very large deposit leaves you with little leverage if the job is delayed or goes wrong. A staged schedule - some at signing, some when materials arrive, the rest on completion - protects both sides. Check your state's rules too; some limit how much a contractor can take upfront.

5. Get the warranty in writing

There are usually two warranties: the manufacturer's warranty on materials, and the contractor's workmanship warranty. The quote should state both, with their length. "Fully warrantied" on its own isn't a warranty.

6. Compare the total with local prices

Prices vary a lot by region, roof pitch, access and material. The fastest way to see where your quote sits is to compare it with what others nearby are quoted for similar work. TrimBil's free quote check does this: upload the quote and you get a fair range for your area, where your price falls in it, and the red flags we spot.

Questions to send before you sign

Can you confirm the number of squares and layers being removed? Which shingle and underlayment products are included? What's inside the "misc." line? Can the payment be staged? What workmanship warranty do you give, in writing? How are extra layers or rotten decking priced if found?

If the answers come back clear and the price sits in the fair range, you've probably got a good quote. If not, you have exactly what you need to negotiate or get a second opinion.

Free, no account, about a minute

Is your roofing quote fair?

Upload it and we'll check it against local prices, line by line.

Check my quote

Common questions

How many roofing quotes should I get?

Two or three is usually enough to see a pattern, as long as each one states the same scope and number of squares.

Can I check my quote for free?

Yes. Upload it on TrimBil's free quote check and you'll get a fair range for your area, red flags and questions to ask. No account needed.

Keep reading.